Skip to main content
replaced http://aviation.stackexchange.com/ with https://aviation.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

Is already the second time we have such a question in a few days:

Why is the fatality rate in the Diamond DA40 so remarkably lower than the SR20/22?Why is the fatality rate in the Diamond DA40 so remarkably lower than the SR20/22?

Why does the Boeing 737 have 5 x the passenger fatalities of the Airbus 320?Why does the Boeing 737 have 5 x the passenger fatalities of the Airbus 320?

As mentioned in the Airbus-vs-Boeing answers, such comparisons are not meaningful, because partial lack of data or impossibility to filter relevant data from global gross figures.

For what I can tell, the answers will then be all in the realm of speculations.

Am I missing something and thus we should allow this kind of questions? Or I understood the situation correctly and we should avoid them?

Is already the second time we have such a question in a few days:

Why is the fatality rate in the Diamond DA40 so remarkably lower than the SR20/22?

Why does the Boeing 737 have 5 x the passenger fatalities of the Airbus 320?

As mentioned in the Airbus-vs-Boeing answers, such comparisons are not meaningful, because partial lack of data or impossibility to filter relevant data from global gross figures.

For what I can tell, the answers will then be all in the realm of speculations.

Am I missing something and thus we should allow this kind of questions? Or I understood the situation correctly and we should avoid them?

Is already the second time we have such a question in a few days:

Why is the fatality rate in the Diamond DA40 so remarkably lower than the SR20/22?

Why does the Boeing 737 have 5 x the passenger fatalities of the Airbus 320?

As mentioned in the Airbus-vs-Boeing answers, such comparisons are not meaningful, because partial lack of data or impossibility to filter relevant data from global gross figures.

For what I can tell, the answers will then be all in the realm of speculations.

Am I missing something and thus we should allow this kind of questions? Or I understood the situation correctly and we should avoid them?

Source Link
Federico
  • 32.7k
  • 1
  • 21
  • 60

Should we allow specific accident rate comparisons questions?

Is already the second time we have such a question in a few days:

Why is the fatality rate in the Diamond DA40 so remarkably lower than the SR20/22?

Why does the Boeing 737 have 5 x the passenger fatalities of the Airbus 320?

As mentioned in the Airbus-vs-Boeing answers, such comparisons are not meaningful, because partial lack of data or impossibility to filter relevant data from global gross figures.

For what I can tell, the answers will then be all in the realm of speculations.

Am I missing something and thus we should allow this kind of questions? Or I understood the situation correctly and we should avoid them?