Skip to main content
m
Source Link
user14897
user14897

@kevin writesGiven that:

One member of the community leaves a note, another member comes along and picks up what is left. Overall the community functions well: we provided an answer to the OP.

Well, how is SE then different from the typical forum/message board? So often comments were wrong and were upvoted (and they can't be downvoted).

  • Partial answers are allowed
  • Wiki answers are allowed

So I'm sorry, but that argument does not stand. UnlessNo "bits" have a place in comments—unless turning SE into a message board is the goal.

@kevin writes:

One member of the community leaves a note, another member comes along and picks up what is left. Overall the community functions well: we provided an answer to the OP.

Well, how is SE then different from the typical forum/message board? So often comments were wrong and were upvoted (and they can't be downvoted).

  • Partial answers are allowed
  • Wiki answers are allowed

So I'm sorry, but that argument does not stand. Unless turning SE into a message board is the goal.

Given that:

  • Partial answers are allowed
  • Wiki answers are allowed

No "bits" have a place in comments—unless turning SE into a message board is the goal.

Source Link
user14897
user14897

@kevin writes:

One member of the community leaves a note, another member comes along and picks up what is left. Overall the community functions well: we provided an answer to the OP.

Well, how is SE then different from the typical forum/message board? So often comments were wrong and were upvoted (and they can't be downvoted).

  • Partial answers are allowed
  • Wiki answers are allowed

So I'm sorry, but that argument does not stand. Unless turning SE into a message board is the goal.