1
$\begingroup$

This question was closed as a duplicate of two others.

I feel this happens often enough that there perhaps needs to be a more satisfactory resolution of duplicate/overlapping questions.

It seems to me that there would be some merit in merging the questions and gathering the answers together.

  • Is there a means to do this?

  • At the very least, could it be possible to construct a community wiki question and answer that provides a canonical answer to which annotation at the top of the other questions would direct viewers?

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

Yes, answers from two different questions can be merged.

The answers from one question are migrated to the other, and former is closed as a duplicate of the latter.

However, this is only appropriate if they are exact duplicates: that is, if every answer to the first question is an appropriate answer to the second. Often we close A as a duplicate of B because the answers to B happen to contain information about A, but A and B are sufficiently different that answers to each should be different.

This is a moderator-only feature, so if you think two questions should be merged, you should raise a custom flag on one of the questions and explain exactly how the merge should happen.

Quoting from Jeff Atwood, Improved Question Merging:

Our kinder, gentler question merge has none of these problems! It behaves much more like a typical duplicate close, with the exception that the answers are migrated to the target question. [...]

If you believe [two questions] should be merged, flag them for moderator attention and indicate what you believe the merge target should be. (Yes, merging is still a moderator only function at the moment.) If the moderator agrees, the merge will happen.

(I believe that blog post describes the current implementation. If not, it's very similar. Example of two recently merged questions from SFF, which had the unusual side-effect that a question was answered nine months before it was asked: https://scifi.meta.stackexchange.com/q/6500/3567)

$\endgroup$

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .